Home | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use                

How is auto insurance (a contracted business service within a capitalist economy) legally enforceable?

Posted by in Sunday, February 19th 2012
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Question by CogitoErgoCogitoSum: How is auto insurance (a contracted business service within a capitalist economy) legally enforceable?
How can a government, who supposedly stays as far out of a capitalist economy as possible, enforce that you purchase auto insurance? Isnt that a consumers right to buy or not buy?

One could argue that the privilege to drive at all is granted by the government, and you should abide by their requirements. But by that logic, wouldnt having insurance first be a prerequisite before you could get licensed?

Best answer:

Answer by Schmoolie
No, your logic is flawed. In this country we insure cars, not drivers. It is not driving that is illegal but driving a car which is not insured. I agree with a point you suggest however, in that I think we should insure drivers, not cars. Thus the government could colect a fee fro every driver and enforce a minimum insurance police on every driver then leave it to drivers to obtain more insurance if they want.

Add your own answer in the comments!

Comments
Crazy Macaro Said:

First.. I might be ignorant but I thought the USA was the first capitalistic country of the world, so by “that logic” how can their government try to stay “out of it” as much as possible?? If a country is capitalistic, you’d think that it is because of the government that it has and nothing else.

But anyway, call me an idiot or a dancing fool (I am dancing right now..) and here’s to your question.

It is all about not being able to save up 10 grand, isn’t it? Or is it all about having to show off your masculine attributes by having a car that’s flashier than mine? Or a mixture of both and who knows how many more ridiculous factors
Think about it. I mean.. how difficult is it to get car insurance nowadays?
If you are able to buy a car with your own money, maybe you don’t have anything to prove and so you just need a car for transport.. you know.. something that’s 10 years old will then do.

You don’t live beyond your means as you have a brain and can use it and so there’s plenty of cash in the bank. After all there have been years of plenty (haven’t there?)

So you are now buying something that hasn’t had a tough life, not very sporty at all and not too fashionable but sound, it won’t cost you the earth as it isn’t fashionable and so with not even 3 grand you get something that’s done 27.000 miles and has service history.

Maybe get some new tyres and brakes as it’s been garaged for the last 9 years and the tyres cracked and the brakes got a bit glazed.. give it a full service and a new battery. Maybe it’ll be another $ 1500.. so..newly serviced, spanking new tyres, brakes wow.. it’ll serve you for the next 10 years now won’t it. For less than 5 grand.

Now you can get liability coverage for it. Get medical coverage for your self and passengers and that’s it. You don’t need full coverage.
You are a good driver so you have never had a claim in the last 15 years and so your insurance will now cost you about $ 42.50 a month.
That’s peanuts.. most people you know spend that much on BEER in just a week end.. but no..

Maybe your insurance il $ 395 a month because you claimed 3 times in as many years and have no money saved up to buy the latest, flashest model and so in the end it isn’t your fault but the government’s.

But this I mean in general.. not especially YOU..


Leave a Reply